Persecution of Palestinian citizens recalls S. Africa apartheid repression
Adri Nieuwhof and Bangani Ngeleza, The Electronic Intifada, 19 May 2010

A South African is carried away after being injured by police at an anti-apartheid demonstration in Cape Province, 1985. (UN Photo)

Two weeks after Israel imposed a travel ban on him, Ameer Makhoul, a well-respected Palestinian leader holding Israeli citizenship, was kidnapped from his home on 6 May in the middle of the night. The persecution of Makhoul brings back memories of the South Africa apartheid regime: he has been heldincommunicado and was not allowed access to his lawyer for two weeks; a court order prohibited publication of any information on the case against Makhoul for 90 days; and the so-called evidence justifying the “security charges” against Makhoul remains secret. During the South Africa anti-apartheid movement, similar tactics were used against those advocating for freedom and equal rights, who were accused of terrorism and having links with the Soviet Union.

The detention of Ameer Makhoul follows a wave of repression of Palestinian leaders and activists resisting the occupation in the West Bank, and he is not the only Palestinian community leader in Israel to be receiving such treatment. Internationally-renowned pharmacologist Dr. Omar Said was detained two weeks before Makhoul and a gag order was used to silence the media. Detentions and gag orders are imposed by Israel to intimidate and harass those who speak out and campaign for freedom and equal rights.

The secrecy around the detention of Makhoul and Said is disturbing, because there is no way to determine if their rights are being respected, and human rights organizations have documented Israel’s systematic abuse of Palestinian political prisoners’ rights. Makhoul wasn’t even present for the closed-door hearing at the Petach Tikva court during which his detention was extended. Meanwhile, Said has been subjected to continuous interrogation and allowed a very limited amount of sleep since his arrest on 24 April. Makhoul’s attorneys suspect that Makhoul was subject to torture during the 12 days he was prevented from meeting with his legal defense team, and the lawyers’ request for the court to release Makhoul’s medical records was refused.

The gag order prevents the Israeli press from exposing the secret “evidence” behind Israel’s espionage allegations against Makhoul and Said. Similar accusations drove former Knesset member and community leader Azmi Bishara into self-imposed exile to avoid ending up in prison. Hussein Abu Hussein, a lawyer who has defended several Palestinians in Israel against charges of spying, told the Israeli daily Haaretz that espionage laws in Israel were so wide-ranging that an Internet chat or telephone conversation with anyone in an “enemy state” could lead to prosecution. However, Israel’s strategy of branding the Palestinian struggle for freedom and equal rights as “terrorist” is not new and the similarities between Israel’s behavior and apartheid South Africa’s oppression of anti-apartheid activists are striking.

South Africa’s Terrorism Act No. 83 of 1967 allowed for the indefinite detention of an individual for terrorism, which was very broadly defined to include anyone they suspected of being engaged or involved in any act against the state. Persons could be held indefinitely since the act allowed detention until all questions were satisfactorily answered or until no further useful purpose would be achieved by keeping the person in detention. The act gave the state the authority to interrogate and to extract information while the public and the families of detainees were not entitled to any information including even the identity or whereabouts of persons detained. Detainees could literally and effectively disappear.

This legislation effectively gave the state license to take away activists’ human rights and avoid accountability. Many were kidnapped and imprisoned under this legislation; this law was invoked in the kidnapping and sentencing of Eric Ngeleza and some of his comrades in 1977 for their membership with the banned African National Congress (ANC) and for facilitating the safe passage of freedom fighters into ANC camps outside South Africa. They were branded as terrorists, interrogated and sentenced to long prison terms on Robben Island. In Ngeleza’s case, it would be ten years before he was reunited with his family. This fate should not be allowed to befall Makhoul, Said and many other activists whose only “crime” is demanding equal rights in the land of their birth.

The new Israeli military order — order 1650, for the “Prevention of Infiltration” — also parallels apartheid South Africa’s racist pass laws. The military order defines anyone who enters the West Bank illegally as an infiltrator, as well as a person who is present in the area and does not lawfully hold a permit. The current South African government protested the order as “a gross violation of an individual’s human rights,” comparing it the notoriously oppressive policy of the apartheid era.

Israel’s treatment of Makhoul and Said, so similar to the application of the Terrorism Act in South Africa and other oppressive measures, confirm that Israel is an apartheid state that has no regard for the rights of its own citizens. It is long overdue for Israel, like apartheid South Africa in its time, to be declared a pariah state and isolated until it agrees to respect human rights.

Adri Nieuwhof and Bangani Ngeleza are independent consultants from Switzerland and South Africa, respectively. Nieuwhof supported the South African anti-apartheid struggle as a member of the Holland Committee on Southern Africa. Ngeleza participated in the liberation struggle as an activist with the African National Congress. When he was 11, his father Eric Ngeleza was sentenced to ten years on Robben Island.



  1. kruitvat Post author

    1. 19 mai 21:13 PLANET TECHNOLOGIES, Hoeven, Noord-Brabant, Pays-Bas
    2. 19 mai 21:17 NC Numericable S.A., Nice, Provence-Alpes-Cote d’Azur, France
    3. 19 mai 21:25 Telecom Italia, Florence, Toscana, Italie
    4. 19 mai 21:28 Telecom Italia, Viareggio, Toscana, Italie
    5. 19 mai 21:30 Free SAS, Épinal, Lorraine, France
    6. 19 mai 21:31 Telenet N.V. Residentials, Mechelen, Antwerpen, Belgique
    7. 19 mai 21:33 TEO LT, AB, Kaunas, Kauno Apskritis, Lituanie
    8. 19 mai 21:35 Neuf Cegetel, Saint-herblain, Pays de la Loire, France
    9. 19 mai 21:36 France Telecom, Moustoir-ac, Bretagne, France
    10. 19 mai 21:39 Vodafone Omnitel N.V., Bardolino, Veneto, Italie
    11. 19 mai 21:40 France Telecom, Champtoceaux, Pays de la Loire, France
    12. 19 mai 21:42 SBC Internet Services, San Jose, California, États-Unis
    13. 19 mai 21:44 Tiscali SpA, Rignano Flaminio, Lazio, Italie
    14. 19 mai 21:45 Deutsche Telekom AG, Mainz, Rheinland-Pfalz, Allemagne
    15. 19 mai 21:48 Telecom Italia, Bergamo, Lombardia, Italie
    16. 19 mai 21:51 CAIW Diensten BV, Poeldijk, Zuid-Holland, Pays-Bas
    17. 19 mai 21:51 Transperfect Translations, Brooklyn, New York, États-Unis
    18. 19 mai 21:56 IUnet, San Severo, Puglia, Italie
    19. 19 mai 21:56 NC Numericable S.A., Marcq-en-baroeul, Nord-Pas-de-Calais, France
    20. 19 mai 22:03 Tiscalinet, Cagliari, Sardegna, Italie
    21. 19 mai 22:04 Telecom Italia, Venice, Veneto, Italie
    22. 19 mai 22:05 British Telecommunications, London, London, City of, Royaume-Uni
    23. 19 mai 22:06 Vodafone Omnitel N.V., Mestre, Veneto, Italie
    24. 19 mai 22:06 ADSL users, Reykjavík, Gullbringusysla, Islande
    25. 19 mai 22:07 Sky Broadband, Romford, Havering, Royaume-Uni
    26. 19 mai 22:08 Belgacom Skynet, Brussels, Brussels Hoofdstedelijk Gewest, Belgique
    27. 19 mai 22:09 Fastweb, Rome, Lazio, Italie
    28. 19 mai 22:11 IUnet, Leghorn, Toscana, Italie
    29. 19 mai 22:12 Telecom Italia, Ancona, Marche, Italie
    30. 19 mai 22:15 Telecom Italia, Rome, Lazio, Italie
    31. 19 mai 22:23 UAB Verslo tiltas, Jonava, Kauno Apskritis, Lituanie
    32. 19 mai 22:31 Tiscalinet, Rome, Lazio, Italie
    33. 19 mai 22:31 Tiscalinet, Cagliari, Sardegna, Italie
    34. 19 mai 22:38 Neuf Cegetel, Saint-Étienne-du-rouvray, Haute-Normandie, France
    35. 19 mai 22:40 Sympatico, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
    36. 19 mai 22:40 Kabel Deutschland Breitband Services GmbH, Berlin, Allemagne
    37. 19 mai 22:43 France Telecom, Rennes, Bretagne, France
    38. 19 mai 22:43 H3G Italy, Pioltello, Lombardia, Italie
    39. 19 mai 22:44 Maroc Telecom, Meknès, Meknes, Maroc
    40. 19 mai 22:49 SMART TELECOM, Dublin, Irlande
    41. 19 mai 22:49 NET Serviços de Comunicação S.A., Belo Horizonte, Minas Gerais, Brésil
    42. 19 mai 22:55 SC Lithuanian Radio and TV Center, Vilnius, Vilniaus Apskritis, Lituanie
    43. 19 mai 22:55 Telecom Italia, Casamassima, Puglia, Italie
    44. 19 mai 23:00 XS4ALL Internet BV, Honselersdijk, Zuid-Holland, Pays-Bas
    45. 19 mai 23:03 Telecom Italia, Zollino, Puglia, Italie
    46. 19 mai 23:11 Comcast Cable, Mchenry, Illinois, États-Unis
    47. 19 mai 23:12 TEO LT, AB, Siauliai, Siauliu Apskritis, Lituanie
    48. 19 mai 23:13 OKCom S.p.A., Rome, Lazio, Italie
    49. 19 mai 23:17 Vodafone Omnitel N.V., Forlimpopoli, Emilia-Romagna, Italie
    50. 19 mai 23:20 Belgacom Skynet, Brussels, Brussels Hoofdstedelijk Gewest, Belgique

  2. kruitvat Post author

    The arrest and treatment of Ameer Makhoul is the best proof that the Israeli government has a brutal and inhuman face, and is arbitrarily locking up its own citizens.
    I hope that human rights organisations from around the world will fight for his liberation.

  3. kruitvat Post author

    recent visitors 26 mai

    Dendermonde, Oost-Vlaanderen, Belgique
    Ile-de-France, France
    Provence-Alpes-Cote d’Azur, France
    Marcq-en-baroeul, Nord-Pas-de-Calais, France
    Utrecht, Pays-Bas
    Basse-Normandie, France
    Sardegna, Italie
    Montreal, Quebec, Canada
    Manchester, Royaume-Uni
    Casablanca, Maroc
    West-Vlaanderen, Belgique
    Zurich, Suisse
    London, City of, Royaume-Uni
    Noord-Holland, Pays-Bas
    Nordrhein-Westfalen, Allemagne
    Cluj-napoca, Cluj, Roumanie
    Toscana, Italie
    Asturias, Espagne

  4. kruitvat Post author

    Andy Worthington:

    The Guantánamo Archive: 3 Years, 650 Articles Listed Chronologically |

    Yesterday I published a list, with links, of all my articles over the last six months in chronological order, as the latest installment of a project to list all my articles in chronological order, which I began in January, when I published five lists covering the period from May 2007 (when I began b…

  5. kruitvat Post author

    ETHNIC CLEANSING: far-right in Israel – Geert Wilders in Holland

    Since 2001, Israeli Minister of Foreign Affairs Avigdor Lieberman, proposes to establish four townships in the occupied West Bank, hermetically sealed, which would be grouped the Palestinians. He sees it as a solution for the Palestinian citizens of Israel, who are more than one million, to move the vast majority of the group in tightly closed, self-administered areas.
    Thus would arise a State ethnically homogeneous from the Mediterranean Sea until the Jordan, sheltering in its midst Palestinian “Bantustans”.


    Geert Wilders to spread his anti-Muslim movement west
    Dutch far-right politician forms international alliance to attempt to ban immigration from Islamic countries

    AP in The Hague
    The Guardian, Friday 16 July 2010

    Dutch far-right lawmaker Geert Wilders wants the Western world to ban immigration from Islamic countries. Photograph: Ben Stansall/AFP/Getty Images
    An anti-Muslim populist in the Netherlands is forming an international alliance to spread his message across the west in an attempt to ban immigration from Islamic countries, among other goals.

    Geert Wilders, leader of the Freedom party, told the Associated Press that he would launch the movement late this year, initially in five countries: the US, Canada, Britain, France and Germany.

    “The message, ‘stop Islam, defend freedom’, is a message that’s not only important for the Netherlands but for the whole free Western world,” Wilders said at the Dutch parliament.

    Among the group’s aims will be outlawing immigration from Islamic countries to the west and a ban on Islamic sharia law. Starting as a grassroots movement, he hopes it eventually will produce its own lawmakers or influence other legislators.

    Ayhan Tonca, a prominent spokesman for Dutch Muslims, said he feared Wilders message would fall on fertile ground in much of Europe, where anti-Islam sentiment has been swelling for years.

    “So long as things are going badly with the economy, a lot of people always need a scapegoat,” Tonca said. “At the moment, that is the Muslims in western Europe.”

    Tonca called on “well-meaning people in Europe to oppose this.”

    Known for his bleached-blond mop of hair, Wilders is a shrewd politician who has won awards in the Netherlands for his debating skills and regularly stands up for gay and women’s rights.

    But he rose to local and then international prominence with his firebrand anti-Islam rhetoric that has led to him being charged under Dutch anti-hate speech laws and banned from visiting Britain until a court there ordered that he be allowed into the country.

    Wilders said he hopes to position the alliance between traditional conservative parties and far-right wing groups, saying that in Britain there is “an enormous gap” between the ruling Conservative party and the far-right BNP: “The BNP is a party that, whatever you think of it, it’s not my party I think it’s a racist party,” he said.

    Wilders, who calls Islam a “fascist” religion, has won increasing support the Netherlands in recent years even while he has been subjected to round-the-clock protection because of death threats.

    His Freedom party won the biggest gains in a national election last month, coming third with 24 seats in the 150-seat parliament, up from the nine before the election.

    However, mainstream parties will not form a coalition with Wilders, leaving him on the margins of Dutch politics for the next parliamentary term.

    Wilders is due to stand trial in October on hate speech charges stemming from his short internet film Fitna, which denounced the Qur’an as a a fascist book that inspires terrorism. The film aroused anti-Dutch protests around the Muslim world, and he was banned for several months from entering Britain.

    But he is unrepentant and said he now wants to take his message outside the Netherlands.

    “The fight for freedom and (against) Islamisation as I see it is a worldwide phenomenon and problem to be solved,” he said.

    Wilders declined to name any of the other founders of the organisation he is calling the Geert Wilders International Freedom Alliance. He has been criticised for running his party as a one-man show.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s